Wordy Wednesday – “Silas Marner” by George Eliot
I wasn’t impressed with this novel.
I liked the characters, many of whom were humorously written, but the overall story was only okay. It’s about love and redemption and doing the right thing – and while I’m interested in those things, none of them were executed in a unique or new fashion here.
Maybe for its time it was new, but I suspect it wasn’t and refuse to do any responsible research into the matter.
If you want a little picture of England in the mid-18th century, maybe this novel would have a few crumbs for you. I hear it is fairly accurate – it’s big on “realism” is what I keep seeing.
If you want a novel that entertains, it does have a handful of good moments, but if you want a novel that makes you think or leaves a strong impression, look elsewhere (maybe Moby Dick, if you have the patience? Or Kokoro, recently blogged about here by a handsome man).
One of my main problems with Silas Marner was that the character I thought would be the main villain just disappears. We get an explanation right at the end of the novel but it’s not terribly satisfying.
Skip this one.
But wait! Then I learned more awful things about this mediocre book!
The film Black Snake Moan is supposedly based on Silas Marner, but the plot synopsis on Wikipedia looks like the film is a confused and incoherent waste of everyone’s time! So it looks like you should stay away from everything connected to Silas Marner.
Posted on February 22, 2012, in Wordy Wednesdays and tagged black snake moan, george eliot, silas marner, snooze fest. Bookmark the permalink. 3 Comments.
oh man, everything is HOTTER down south!
from the director of a movie you’ve never heard of, but are thankful you’ve never seen!
The poster tells me justin timberlake is in it too….. i feel like all 3 of them shouldv been on the poster.